Puckett & Faraj

Despite the public outcry, the Navy SEALs are still facing special courts-martial after their January 2010 arraignments; SO1 Huertas and SO2 Keefe in April and SO2 McCabe in May 2010.

Military Judges Rule on Motions

The military judge in the Huertas and Keefe case closed the last motion hearing by directing the April courts-martial be held in Baghdad so the Iraqi detainee would be present to testify live in the courtroom.  The government declined to attempt to bring the detainee to Norfolk for the trials.  The military judge determined the defense attorney’s request for the Constitutional right to confrontation required the Iraqi detainee to be present.  The government request to depose the detainee was denied, and the entire cadre to support two special courts-martial will travel to Iraq.

A second military judge, ruling on the McCabe case, upheld the government request for a deposition but did not move the court-martial to Iraq.  The special court-martial will be held in Norfolk, VA, beginning on May 3, 2010.

General Cancels Deposition

Since those two military judge’s rulings, Major General Cleveland has canceled the government trip to Iraq to depose the detainee.   This leaves the SO2 McCabe defense and government teams without the Iraqi detainee’s presence or sworn statements as evidence in the case.

Press  Release:  The trial of SO2 Matthew McCabe has been moved from January 19, 2010 to May 3, 2010 in Norfolk, VA.  The Military Judge ruled that the government request for a delay was approved.  However, she did not move the court-martial to Iraq as did the Military Judge in the cases of the other two Navy SEALs charged in the case.

A different Military Judge in the cases of SO2 Keefe and SO1 Huertas ordered the cases be tried in Iraq to accommodate the defense requests for the detainee to be present after declining to accept a deposition.  The SO2 Keefe Case is scheduled to begin on 5 April 2010 and SO1 Heurtas is scheduled to begin on 19 April 2010.